Skip to main content

Francis Fukuyama is right: Socialism is the only alternative to liberalism

In Liberalism and Its Discontents, Francis Fukuyama diagnoses the political and psychological malaise caused by capitalism. His analysis makes one thing clear: liberalism is incapable of addressing the social, economic, and ecological crises it faces.
  
by Samuel McIlhagga 

Part 2 - Intellectual Origins

The publication of The End of History and the Last Man coincided with the sudden collapse of the Soviet Union, the reunification of Germany, and the independence of various Soviet satellite states like Poland and Lithuania. Initially, all these post-Soviet states adopted liberal, democratic, and capitalist models of governance. Accordingly, Fukuyama became a both famous and somewhat misunderstood figure in academia ā€” a prophet of the triumph of liberal democracy and the material inevitability of capitalism.

In the press, he was written about as a reverse Karl Marx. For those who had not read his book, the lesson to be taken from it was that history was over because American capitalism had won against the Soviet Union. Indeed, in the aftermath of 9/11, journalists, who had misunderstood the book, attempted to contact Fukuyama to ask if history had started again.

However, Fukuyama is distinct from the political-economic partisans of free trade and laissez-faire capitalism like Friedrich Hayek, Ludwig von Mises, and Milton Friedman ā€” men who defended the price mechanism as a more rational means of distributing and allocating resources. Instead, Fukuyama is a writer and political scientist deeply concerned with how humans, and their supposed transcendent psyches, operate within specific historical political, economic, and cultural systems.

Although he no longer identifies as a neoconservative, like many of that coterie, Fukuyama is deeply concerned with transhistorical and universal ideals. The failure of the Iraq War, a major neoconservative project that Fukuyama initially supported, seems to have pushed him away from the view that liberalism, democracy, and capitalism occur naturally if the ground is cleared by ā€œwell-intentionedā€ interventions.

Yet his political idealism still runs deep. Born in Chicago in 1952, Fukuyamaā€™s family moved east to Manhattan. His family background contains academic, religious, and mercantile strains. Fukuyamaā€™s paternal first-generation Japanese immigrant grandfather ran a hardware store on the West Coast, while his maternal grandfather was a prominent academic economist and university administrator at Kyoto University. His father was an academic sociologist and minister in the Congregational Church ā€” a bastion of bourgeois liberal and puritan religious idealism. The emphasis Fukuyama places on democratic self-management, political-moral predestination, and individual autonomy within a liberal ā€œpriesthood of all believersā€ seems to be a secularized holdover of his Calvinism.

In 1970, Fukuyama started his undergraduate career at Cornell in classics: he is in many ways a classical political thinker. One can see the influence of ancient Greek political theory everywhere. For instance, Fukuyama takes an interest in the basic Aristotelian units of politics (monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy) and their relation to liberal modernity, and continues to use the Platonic theory of the soul (divided between reason (logos), spirit (thymos), and appetite (eros) to describe eternal human nature and its need for recognition. During his time at Cornell, Fukuyama fell in with the philosopher and classicist professor Allan Bloom, best known for his 1987 book The Closing of the American Mind, which criticized the practice of moral relativism and historical contextualism at American universities.

Bloom, who was taught by the philosophers Leo Strauss and Alexandre KojĆØve, introduced Fukuyama to an idealist intellectual tradition stretching back to Hegel. Strauss influenced the conservative academy with his Natural Right and History (1953), which argued for a transcendent and transhistorical set of naturally occurring rights that might provide politics with a moral compass.

Straussā€™s followers in America developed an approach to interpreting political texts that emphasized perennial problems and the power of the authored text to independently generate meaning. KojĆØve was an unorthodox Marxist thinker, French economic administrator in the European Common Market, and neo-Hegelian who reintegrated the German philosopherā€™s thinking on history into contemporary politics. His 1946 Introduction to the Reading of Hegel proposed an earlier theory of the ā€œend of historyā€ that influenced Fukuyamaā€™s own thesis. KojĆØve suggested that the rational Napoleonic Empireā€™s victory over the absolutist Prussian state at Jena in 1806 represented the apex of human political possibility: the parameters of all future political action were drawn by Napoleon at Jena.

After Cornell, Fukuyama spent time in a comparative literature program at Yale and studied under the post-structuralists Roland Barthes and Jacques Derrida in Paris, before switching to political science at Harvard. While Fukuyama would become engaged with the empirical quantitative and qualitative study of hard-nosed foreign policy and international relations, he retained a deep interest in the text and human ideals, which he carried to the RAND Corporation, the State Department, and advisory roles under Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush.

The success of his 1989 National Interest Article ā€œThe End of History?ā€ resulted in a $600,000 advance to write a follow-up ā€” The End of History and the Last Man. This pushed Fukuyama back into writing and academia, where he popularized the idealism of his intellectual precursors.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Zuckerberg changes camp in the capitalist civil war, joins the Musk-led oligarchy

globinfo freexchange   It was Mark Zuckerberg this time that decided to change camp in the capitalist civil war, in order to join the Musk-led oligarchy under the oncoming presidency of oligarchy's puppet.   The move by Meta to end its third-party fact-checking program and move to a so-called community notes model, has been justifiably widely interpreted as an attempt by Zuckerberg to ingratiate himself with the incoming Trump administration, which has long denounced the moderation policy as censorship with a left-wing bias.   From the first moments in his interview with Joe Rogan, Zuckerberg attempted to justify his previous policy regarding censorship practices in Facebook, claiming that he was receiving high pressure from the Democratic party to do so! The ex-liberal billionaire oligarch made an impressive 180 degrees turn, claiming that he knew that there was something wrong with the specific policy and that he tried to fight back against the pressure to imple...

Jabalia, Khan Yunis, Rafah: The spots of Zionist barbarism and genocide in Gaza will become the graveyard of US imperialism

by system failure   It is certainly not the first genocide in human history, but it is the first one transmitted in real time. For over a year now, we witnessed the horror in Gaza, a place that has been turned into a real hell on earth by the fascist Israeli state and the Zionist barbarism.   It didn't start in October 7, 2023, as the Western and the Zionist propaganda wants you to believe. Before that, we had decades of  colonization, torture, brutal suppression, de-humanization, resulting in a slow-motion genocide in process by the Israeli state against Palestinians.  The events of October 7, only gave the pretext to the Israeli regime accelerate the genocidal process and literally flatten Gaza, killing thousands of civilians at an unprecedented rate.     The corporate media of the West covered outrageously the events since October 7, resulting in a despicable effort - even now - to whitewash Israel for its crimes. There are no words to describe the ...

It is Russia that surprised the imperialist West in Syria, not the other way round

by system failure   The rapid fall of Bashar al-Assad in Syria surprised most of the people who follow closely the Syrian crisis from its beginning. At a time where there was not a single sign that the Salafi Jihadists could revive and take over Damascus, a rebranded Al-Qaeda finally did it, just in a few days, almost without any resistance by the Syrian Army and its allies.  The Western corporate media celebrated the fall of Assad, yet an atmosphere of perplexity and uncertainty shortly replaced the celebrating climate, mostly due to the fact that the new authority in Syria was the one that had been previously classified by the imperialist West as Islamic terrorism.   The major Western outlets immediately lunched a massive operation to whitewash Abu Mohammad al-Julani, in an effort to transform the new leader of Syria, from a radical Islamic terrorist, to a kind of moderate and even secular figure, who respects all religions and ethnic groups. The whole effort would be r...

ĪŸ ĪµĪŗĻƒĻ…Ī³Ļ‡ĻĪæĪ½Ī¹ĻƒĻ„Ī®Ļ‚ Ļ„Ī·Ļ‚ Ī“Ī¹Ī±Ļ†ĪøĪæĻĪ¬Ļ‚: ĪŒĪ»Ī· Ī· Ī±Ī»Ī®ĪøĪµĪ¹Ī± Ī³Ī¹Ī± Ļ„Īæ Ī²ĻĻŒĪ¼Ī¹ĪŗĪæ ĻƒĻĻƒĻ„Ī·Ī¼Ī± Ī£Ī·Ī¼ĪÆĻ„Ī· Ļ€ĪæĻ… ĻƒĻ…Ī½ĪµĻ‡ĪÆĪ¶ĪµĪ¹ Ī½Ī± ĪŗĪ±Ļ„Ī±ĻƒĻ„ĻĪ­Ļ†ĪµĪ¹ Ļ„Ī· Ļ‡ĻŽĻĪ± Ī¼Ī­ĻƒĪ± Ī±Ļ€ĻŒ Ļ„Īæ ĪŗĪ±ĪøĪµĻƒĻ„ĻŽĻ‚ ĪœĪ·Ļ„ĻƒĪæĻ„Ī¬ĪŗĪ·

* ĪšĪµĪÆĪ¼ĪµĪ½Īæ ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ podcast Ī±Ļ€ĻŒ Ļ„ĪæĪ½ ĪšĻŽĻƒĻ„Ī± Ī’Ī±Ī¾ĪµĪ²Ī¬Ī½Ī· Ī¤ĪæĪ½ ĪšĻŽĻƒĻ„Ī± Ī£Ī·Ī¼ĪÆĻ„Ī·, Ī±Ī½Ī±Ī¼Ļ†ĪÆĪ²ĪæĪ»Ī± ĪøĪ± Ļ„ĪæĪ½ ĪŗĻĪÆĪ½ĪµĪ¹ Ī· Ī™ĻƒĻ„ĪæĻĪÆĪ±, ĻŒĻ€Ļ‰Ļ‚ Ī»Ī­Ī³ĪµĻ„Ī±Ī¹ Ī¼Ī¬Ī»Ī»ĪæĪ½ ĪµĪŗ Ļ„ĪæĻ… Ļ€ĪæĪ½Ī·ĻĪæĻ Ī±Ļ…Ļ„Ī­Ļ‚ Ļ„Ī¹Ļ‚ Ī¼Ī­ĻĪµĻ‚, Ī±Ī»Ī»Ī¬ Ļ„ĪæĪ½ Ļ€ĻĻŽĻ„Īæ Ī»ĻŒĪ³Īæ Ī­Ļ‡ĪæĻ…Ī½ Ī±Ļ…Ļ„ĪæĪÆ Ļ„ĪæĻ…Ļ‚ ĪæĻ€ĪæĪÆĪæĻ…Ļ‚ ĪµĪ¾Ī±Ļ€Ī¬Ļ„Ī·ĻƒĪµ. Ī¤Īæ Ļ€ĻĪæĻ†ĪÆĪ» Ļ„ĪæĻ… Ī”Ļ‰ĻĪ¹ĪŗĪæĻ Ļ€Ī±Ī½ĪµĻ€Ī¹ĻƒĻ„Ī·Ī¼Ī¹Ī±ĪŗĪæĻ ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ ĻƒĪæĪ²Ī±ĻĪæĻ Ļ€ĪæĪ»Ī¹Ļ„Ī¹ĪŗĪæĻ Ļ€ĪæĻ… Ļ†Ī¹Ī»ĪæĻ„ĪµĻ‡Ī½ĪµĪÆĻ„Ī±Ī¹ ĻƒĻ„Ī· Ī¼ĪµĻ„Ī¬ ĪøĪ¬Ī½Ī±Ļ„Īæ Ī±Ļ€ĪæĻ„ĪÆĪ¼Ī·ĻƒĪ· Ļ„Ī·Ļ‚ Ļ€ĻĪæĻƒĻ‰Ļ€Ī¹ĪŗĻŒĻ„Ī·Ļ„Ī¬Ļ‚ Ļ„ĪæĻ…, ĪµĪÆĪ½Ī±Ī¹ Ī¼Ī¹Ī± Ī±ĪŗĻŒĪ¼Ī· Ī±Ļ€ĻŒĪ“ĪµĪ¹Ī¾Ī· ĻŒĻ„Ī¹ ĻƒĻ„Ī¬ĪøĪ·ĪŗĪµ ĻƒĻ„Ī· ĻƒĻ‰ĻƒĻ„Ī® (Ī³Ī¹Ī± Ļ„Ī· Ī“Ī¹Ī±Ļ€Ī»ĪæĪŗĪ®) Ļ€Ī»ĪµĻ…ĻĪ¬ Ļ„Ī·Ļ‚ Ī™ĻƒĻ„ĪæĻĪÆĪ±Ļ‚. Ī¦Ļ…ĻƒĪ¹ĪŗĪ¬, Ī³Ī¹Ī± Ļ„ĪæĪ½ Ļ€ĻĻŽĪ·Ī½ Ļ€ĻĻ‰ĪøĻ…Ļ€ĪæĻ…ĻĪ³ĻŒ Ī­Ļ‡ĪµĪ¹ ĪŗĪ¬ĪøĪµ Ī“Ī¹ĪŗĪ±ĪÆĻ‰Ī¼Ī± Ī½Ī± Ļ€ĪµĪ½ĪøĪµĪÆ, Īæ ĪšĻ…ĻĪ¹Ī¬ĪŗĪæĻ‚ ĪœĪ·Ļ„ĻƒĪæĻ„Ī¬ĪŗĪ·Ļ‚, Īæ ĪæĻ€ĪæĪÆĪæĻ‚ ĻŒĻ‡Ī¹ Ī¼ĻŒĪ½Īæ Ī­ĪŗĪ±Ī½Īµ Ļ„Ī·Ī½ ĪŗĪ±ĻĪ¹Ī­ĻĪ± Ļ„ĪæĻ… Ļ‰Ļ‚ Ā«ĻĪæĻ…ĻƒĻ†Ī­Ļ„Ī¹ Ī£Ī·Ī¼ĪÆĻ„Ī· ĻƒĻ„Ī·Ī½ Ī•ĪøĪ½Ī¹ĪŗĪ® Ī¤ĻĪ¬Ļ€ĪµĪ¶Ī±Ā», Ī±Ī»Ī»Ī¬ Ļ„ĪæĪ½ Ī±Ī½Ļ„Ī­Ī³ĻĪ±ĻˆĪµ ĻƒĻ„Ī± Ī²Ī±ĻƒĪ¹ĪŗĪ¬ ĻƒĻ„ĪæĪ¹Ļ‡ĪµĪÆĪ± Ļ„Ī·Ļ‚ Ļ€ĪæĪ»Ī¹Ļ„Ī¹ĪŗĪ®Ļ‚ Ļ„ĪæĻ…. ĪŸ ĪœĪ·Ļ„ĻƒĪæĻ„Ī±ĪŗĪ¹ĻƒĪ¼ĻŒĻ‚ Ī“ĪµĪ½ ĪµĪÆĪ½Ī±Ī¹ Ļ„ĪÆĻ€ĪæĻ„Ī± Ī¬Ī»Ī»Īæ Ī±Ļ€ĻŒ Ļ„ĪæĪ½ Ī£Ī·Ī¼Ī¹Ļ„Ī¹ĻƒĪ¼ĻŒ Ī¼Īµ Ī¬Ī»Ī»Ī±, Ļ€Ī¹Īæ Ī±ĪŗĻĪ±ĪÆĪ± Ī¼Ī­ĻƒĪ±. ĪˆĪ½Ī± ĪŗĪæĪ¹Ī½ĻŒ ĻƒĻ„ĪæĪ¹Ļ‡ĪµĪÆĪæ Ļ€ĪæĻ… ĪµĻ€ĪÆĻƒĪ·Ļ‚ ĪµĪ½Ļ„ĪæĻ€ĪÆĪ¶ĪµĻ„Ī±Ī¹ ĻƒĪµ Ī£Ī·Ī¼ĪÆĻ„Ī· ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ ĪœĪ·Ļ„ĻƒĪæĻ„Ī¬ĪŗĪ·, ĪµĪÆĪ½Ī±Ī¹ ĻŒĻ„Ī¹ ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ ĪæĪ¹ Ī“ĻĪæ, ĪŗĪ±Ļ„Ī¬Ļ†ĪµĻĪ±Ī½ Ī½Ī± Ī±Ļ€ĪæĪŗĻĻĻˆĪæĻ…Ī½ ĻƒĪæĪ²Ī±ĻĪ¬ ĪµĪ»Ī»ĪµĪÆĪ¼Ī¼Ī±Ļ„Ī± ĻƒĻ„Ī·Ī½ ĪŗĪæĪ¹Ī½Ļ‰Ī½Ī¹ĪŗĪ® ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ Ļ€ĪæĪ»Ī¹Ļ„Ī¹ĪŗĪ® Ļ„ĪæĻ…Ļ‚ ĻƒĻ…Ī¼Ļ€ĪµĻĪ¹Ļ†ĪæĻĪ¬, ĪµĻ€Ī¹ĻƒĻ„ĻĪ±Ļ„ĪµĻĪæĪ½Ļ„Ī±Ļ‚ Ī¼Ī¹ĻƒĪøĪæĻ†ĪæĻĪ¹ĪŗĪæĻĻ‚ ĻƒĻ„ĻĪ±Ļ„ĪæĻĻ‚ Ī±Ļ€ĻŒ Ī“Ī·Ī¼ĪæĻƒĪ¹ĪæĪ³ĻĪ¬Ļ†ĪæĻ…Ļ‚ ĪŗĪ±Ī¹ Ī“Ī·Ī¼ĪæĻƒĪŗĻŒĻ€ĪæĻ…Ļ‚. ĪŸ ĪšĻŽĻƒĻ„Ī±Ļ‚ Ī£Ī·Ī¼ĪÆĻ„Ī·Ļ‚ Ī“...

Privatizing Syria: US Plans to Sell Off a Nationā€™s Wealth After Assad

by Kit Klarenberg    Part 2 - ā€˜Reconstruction Projectā€™   Syriaā€™s economic independence and strength under Assadā€™s rule and the benefits reaped by average citizens, as a result, were never acknowledged in the mainstream before or during the decade-long proxy war. Yet, countless reports from major international institutions underline this reality ā€“ which has now been brutally vanquished, never to return. For example, an April 2015 World Health Organization document noted how Damascus ā€œhad one of the best-developed healthcare systems in the Arab world.ā€ Per a 2018 U.N. investigation, ā€œuniversal, free healthcareā€ was extended to all Syrian citizens, who ā€œenjoyed some of the highest levels of care in the region.ā€ Education was likewise free, and before the conflict, ā€œan estimated 97% of primary school-aged Syrian children were attending class, and Syriaā€™s literacy rates were thought to be at over 90% for both men and women.ā€ By 2016, millions were out of school . A U.N. Human ...

Seeking Justice: Tracking IDF War Criminals Around The World

Glenn Greenwald  

The BBCā€™s Civil War Over Gaza

Drop Site News is publishing a landmark investigation about the BBCā€™s coverage of Israelā€™s unrelenting assault on Gaza by British journalist Owen Jones. His report is based on interviews with 13 journalists and other BBC staffers who offer remarkable insights into how senior figures within the BBCā€™s news operation skewed stories in favor of Israelā€™s narratives and repeatedly dismissed objections registered by scores of staffers who, throughout the past 14 months, demanded that the network uphold its commitment to impartiality and fairness.    by Owen Jones   Part 2 - ā€œThis is about editorial standardsā€   In November 2023, BBC senior management attended a morning meeting with at least 100 staffers to discuss coverage of Gaza. It soon descended into a fiery debate. ā€œWeā€™ve got to all remember that this all started on 7 October,ā€ Deborah Turness, the CEO of the news division, called out, in an attempt to assert control of the meeting, two attendees told me. Liliane Lando...

In France, Ordinary Consumers Fund Tax Breaks for the Wealthy

Emmanuel Macronā€™s government gave tax breaks for Franceā€™s wealthiest while counting on purchase taxes paid by ordinary consumers. Now saying it has a budget hole to fill, his administration is again expecting working-class people to pick up the bill.   by Marlon Ettinger Part 1 President Emmanuel Macron picked FranƧois Bayrou as Franceā€™s new prime minister earlier this month, despite his lack of any parliamentary majority. Bayrouā€™s appointment on December 13 came just over a week after his predecessor Michel Barnierā€™s government was felled by a no-confidence vote proposed by the Left and joined by the far right, after Barnier tried to force through his budget without having the numbers in the National Assembly.  The most likely outcome now is that Bayrou, who comes from a party called the Democratic Movement, will reimpose last yearā€™s budget by decree. The National Assembly has already assented to continuing last yearā€™s budget by an emergency vote. Franceā€™s in many ways undemo...

With Trumpā€™s Re-Election, a Venezuela Invasion Could Be On the Cards

The re-election of Donald Trump to the presidency of the United States has many in Venezuela extremely concerned. From assassinations, terror campaigns, sanctions and coups, the first Trump administration tried everything short of a full-scale invasion of the country. With a cabinet full of hawks, MintPress assesses the potential for a future U.S. intervention in Venezuela.   Part 4 - Sanctions, Piracy, and Kidnapping The most far-reaching U.S. action against Venezuela, however, has been the punishing sanctions regime. The economic blockade of the country ā€“ which includes intimidating foreign nations and businesses into ceasing trading with Venezuela ā€“ devastated the country, leading to huge shortages of goods. Although some sanctions have been in place since 2004, they were drastically expanded under the Trump administration. Alfred de Zayas, an (American) United Nations Special Rapporteur who visited the country in 2018, likened the blockade to a ā€œMedieval Siegeā€ and estimated th...

Amnesty International investigation concludes Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza

Part 6 - Accountability for genocide    ā€œThe international communityā€™s seismic, shameful failure for over a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing arms transfers, is and will remain a stain on our collective conscience,ā€ said AgnĆØs Callamard.   ā€œGovernments must stop pretending they are powerless to end this genocide, which was enabled by decades of impunity for Israelā€™s violations of international law. States need to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismay and take strong and sustained international action, however uncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some of Israelā€™s allies.   ā€œThe International Criminal Courtā€™s (ICC) arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes against humanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overdue justice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect for the court...