Skip to main content

Venezuela brings toys to poor kids, gets called ‘Grinch’ on CNN

by Ben Norton

Turning facts on their head, CNN transformed the Venezuelan government’s act of helping the poor into the complete opposite.

In the article “Venezuelan President Called a ‘Grinch’ After Government Toy Seizure” (12/11/16), CNN reporters Rafael Romo and Jorge Luis Pérez liken President Nicolás Maduro to a dastardly Grinch who is stealing toys from under children’s Christmas trees — while he is doing precisely the contrary.

On Sunday, December 11, the Venezuelan government confiscated nearly 4 million toys from the country’s largest toy company. Venezuela’s consumer protection agency said the company was hoarding the toys and planning to sell them at inflated prices in order to maximize profits during the Christmas season. The head of the consumer protection agency charged that executives at the toy company, Kreisel-Venezuela, “don’t care about our children’s right to have a merry Christmas.

The government announced it would give those toys to local committees in impoverished neighborhoods to sell at below-market prices, so poor families can afford gifts for their children. But given the propensity of US corporate media to distort Venezuelan government policies, it’s unsurprising that CNN discounted this explanation.

On CNN‘s website, reporters Romo and Pérez cite anonymous “critics” who claimed “many families won’t be able to buy the confiscated toys for the holiday.” On the cable channel, the “critics” claimed that “many families won’t have any toys to buy their children.

Who are these “critics”? CNN cites just two people, both obscure Twitter users, neither of whom claimed that families now won’t be able to buy toys.

In fact, not until more than halfway through the CNN video broadcast does the report acknowledge the reason the Venezuelan government gives for confiscating these toys. In the final seconds, CNN deigns to include a clip from Maduro, who explains that his actions are precisely the opposite of what the media conglomerate implied: “We have found a case of criminal hoarding of 4 million toys, so the children of our communities, barrios and government committees will for sure have their toys for Christmas, thanks to our laws,” the Venezuelan president declared. “This is like reinforcements for baby Jesus.

Similarly, not until the sixth paragraph does the online article mention the Venezuelan government’s rationale for confiscating the toys, after Maduro is smeared as the “the Grinch that stole Christmas.” (One cannot help but notice that, if anyone were to be compared to the Grinch in this situation, it would be rich corporate executives hoarding toys to maximize profit.)

The deception does not end there. In the article, under a large subhead titled “Worse than the Grinch,” Romo and Pérez write, “‘Now what?’ a Venezuelan woman asked on Twitter, ‘is [President] Nicolás Maduro the modern Grinch?'

The tweet the CNN reporters link to is from an unknown Twitter user with 165 followers, who goes by the name Joli. If readers were to click on the link, they would soon see a thread in which Joli expressed surprise that her tweet inspired a CNN article, adding, “Aunque, no soy venezolana” — “Although, I am not Venezuelan.

Clearly, CNN‘s Romo and Pérez did not try to confirm the identity of the person whose quote they framed their entire article around. Yet the journalists continued with their shoddy reporting, writing, “Another Twitter user told CNN that the Venezuelan government is ‘worse than the Grinch.'

By “told CNN,” Romo and Pérez do not mean they interviewed this person; they mean another unknown Twitter user with 500 followers who goes by the name Mivida tweeted at Romo.

The tweet they linked to, which had no favorites or retweets, also smears Venezuela’s government as a “narco regime” (although that part of the tweet is not cited in the article). A quick glance at Mivida’s Twitter feed shows that it is full of right-wing memes.

CNN‘s “Grinch” report exemplifies a popular new technique: Twitter has become the lazy journalist’s favorite tool. With millions of users expressing millions of different opinions, ostensibly “neutral” news outlets can cite tweets that confirm their biases as putative “evidence” that the public feels a particular way on an issue–a way that almost always just so happens to reflect and serve powerful interests.

Random tweets from unknown users can hence be quoted as examples of anonymous “critics” who echo corporate and government propaganda and rehash conventional wisdom. CNN‘s reporting is a case study in how to further sling mud at an elected socialist government that has for years faced aggression from the United States.

The US government, the interests of which major corporate media networks like CNN so obediently echo, has supported right-wing opposition groups in Venezuela for well over a decade. In fact, in 2002, the US even backed a coup that toppled the democratically elected government of Hugo Chávez, and temporarily replaced it with a right-wing, US-allied regime headed by businessman Pedro Carmona. The same media that continues to demonize Venezuela with outright lies today helped sell the coup then (Extra! Update, 6/02)—although Chávez was so popular, masses of Venezuelans filled the streets and demanded that their elected socialist leader be returned to office, promptly overturning the short-lived 2002 putsch.

The CNN video playlist included with the above article demonstrates this propagandistic tenor. The videos are all extremely negative, and blame “Venezuela’s economic disaster” solely on its government.

If this kind of sloppy reporting were done on a US ally, it could ruin a journalist’s career. But as American economist Mark Weisbrot (Guardian, 3/10/12) put it more than four years ago:

Such is the state of misrepresentation of Venezuela—it is probably the most lied-about country in the world—that a journalist can say almost anything about Chávez or his government and it is unlikely to be challenged, so long as it is negative.

More recently, an investigation in The Nation (6/22/16) by Gabriel Hetland found that while “Venezuela is in the midst of a severe crisis…mainstream media have consistently misrepresented and significantly exaggerated the severity of the crisis.

This suffocating climate lets major media networks get away with portraying progressive government policies that are infinitely more reminiscent of the deeds of Robin Hood, or even of the magnanimous Santa Claus himself, than they are of the greedy green Christmas monster.

Source:


Related:

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why the US rushed to propagate the 'naval mine' scenario to explain recent attacks on two oil tankers in the Gulf of Oman

globinfo freexchange

The incident of the recent attack against two oil tankers in the Gulf of Oman elevated the heat between the US and Iran. Naturally, the attack also produced some level of turmoil in the oil global market.

Trump's hostile attitude against Iran was clearly evident even before his election. His totally unjustifiable and completely incomprehensible action to kill the Iran nuclear deal, destroyed any remnants of US reliability. Consequently, even the US Western allies refused to follow this evidently counterproductive strategy.

Under these circumstances and given the endless history of US manufactured incidents used to justify the start of another war, most people rightfully thought that this has been just another false flag operation.

And it makes sense actually. Why the hell Iran would attempt to blow up its relations with Japan in the midst of Japanese PM Shinzo Abe visit in the country? Only the US empire would have reasons to do it in order to force one of its…

Εθνικές εκλογές 2019: τι μας επιφυλάσσει ο νεοφιλελεύθερος εφιάλτης που επιστρέφει δριμύτερος

Οι προβλέψεις φαίνεται να επαληθεύονται εντυπωσιακά. Όπως είχαμε αναφέρει ήδη από το 2016 και αμέσως μετά την εκλογή Μητσοτάκη στην ηγεσία της ΝΔ, το αποτέλεσμα των εσωτερικών εκλογών στη γαλάζια παράταξη έλυνε τα χέρια του άξονα Βρυξελλών-Βερολίνου. Οι γραφειοφασίστες των Βρυξελλών και το διευθυντήριο του Βερολίνου απέκτησαν μια πρώτης τάξεως εφεδρεία σε περίπτωση που τα πράγματα "στράβωναν" με την κυβέρνηση Τσίπρα.  

globinfo freexchange 

Η κυβέρνηση ΣΥΡΙΖΑ έδωσε κάποια μικρά σημάδια ανυπακοής ενάντια στη λιτότητα που επιβάλλει το νεοφιλελεύθερο ιερατείο, ρέποντας 'επικίνδυνα' προς μια πιο φιλολαϊκή πολιτική. Δεν είναι τυχαίο φυσικά ότι τα πρώτα αυτά σημάδια άρχισαν να γίνονται ορατά μόλις η χώρα βγήκε από το πρόγραμμα επιτήρησης που επέβαλε η Τρόικα (έστω και τυπικά).

Παρόλο που το τοπίο καταστροφής στην οικονομία είναι κάτι παραπάνω από ορατό, λόγω των επιβαλλόμενων καταστροφικών πολιτικών του ΔΝΤ, η κυβέρνηση έσπευσε να εκμεταλλευτεί τα διευρυμένα περιθ…

Την ώρα που ο Μητσοτάκης σχεδιάζει ασφαλιστικό Πινοσέτ, ο πιο δημοφιλής υποψήφιος για την Αμερικανική προεδρία κυρήσσει πόλεμο στις ασφαλιστικές

globinfo freexchange

Σοκ και δέος είχαν προκαλέσει οι δηλώσεις Καραγκούνη το Σεπτέμβριο του 18 περί "ασφαλιστικού Πινοσέτ" προλειαίνοντας το έδαφος για τους σχεδιασμούς μιας πιθανής κυβέρνησης Μητσοτάκη. 
Λίγο πριν τις εκλογές της 7ης Ιουλίου, η ΝΔ έδωσε μια πρόγευση του τι πρόκειται να επακολουθήσει στον τομέα της ασφάλισης. Ορισμένα γαλάζια στελέχη προσπάθησαν να διασκεδάσουν τις εντυπώσεις δηλώνοντας ότι δεν πρόκειται να ιδιωτικοποιηθεί ο ασφαλιστικός κλάδος και υπονοώντας (ως συνήθως) ότι τέτοιες υπερβολές οφείλονται στην "Αριστερή προπαγάνδα".

Όμως η απόλυτη αφοσίωση του σκληρού πυρήνα της γαλάζιας παράταξης στη νεοφιλελεύθερη ιδεολογία είναι κάτι παραπάνω από φανερή. Είναι σχεδόν βέβαιο ότι νεοφιλελεύθεροι 'τζιχαντιστές' της δεξιάς ονειρεύονται πλήρη ιδιωτικοποίηση υγείας, ασφάλισης, παιδείας, ως πρώτο πιάτο στο μενού του νεοφιλελεύθερου 'οδοστρωτήρα'.

Οι μιντιακοί γκεμπελίσκοι και τα δεξιά τρολ κραυγάζουν εναντίον της Αριστερής "ιδεοληψί…

Confirmed: the US empire seeks to 'clear' the path for the invasion of Iran

globinfo freexchange

Sometimes it's quite surprising how fast some estimations appear to be confirmed.

Only four days ago, we wrote that the US imperialists know that an all-out war with Iran would equal a suicide. The goal is probably a 'surgical' invasion on the south shores of the country that would last just as long as to permit the US and allies to control the Strait of Hormuz, and therefore, the global oil market. The first step towards such an operation would be the mine-clearing of the strait.

This probably explains why the Western media insisted to circulate the scenario of the 'naval mine'. They want to drag Western leaderships behind US in an operation to clear the mines in the Strait of Hormuz, in the name of global energy security.

Well, we were quite close actually. Three days later, the US leadership attempted a broader global alignment - including rival countries like China - towards the protection of "freedom of navigation in the region". …

The Greeks have just committed suicide by electing the most fanatically neoliberal government ever

globinfo freexchange

The result of the recent Greek national elections will puzzle future historians for decades. The Greek voters gave a clear victory to the conservative right party, New Democracy, which will govern with 158 seats, without the need to make any coalitions.
It could be characterized a "paradoxical" result mainly for two reasons:
First, the voters gave a clear governmental order to one of the traditional powers of the old political system, which are highly responsible for the Greek crisis that erupted in 2010. Several top names of the new government, and even New Democracy leader, Kyriakos Mitsotakis, have been accused of being involved in various corruption scandals, in the not so distant past.
Second, the fact that the voters elected perhaps the most fanatically neoliberal government ever. This means that Mitsotakis administration is expected to implement the brutal neoliberal policies imposed by Greece's creditors to the letter. Recall that those polic…

Masks fall at last: Bernie officially declares war on corporate Dems who seek to survive around Warren

globinfo freexchange

On early June, Politico published an article which actually unfolded, in plain sight, the plans of the corporate branch of the Democratic party to stop Bernie Sanders.
As we wrote back then:

This is an amazingly straight admission by the establishment apparatus, concerning a certain strategy as part of the whole anti-Sanders operation. And it is also clear that Elizabeth Warren is establishment's key player around this strategy.

Perhaps it's not accidental that this article was published right after Elizabeth Warren signaled to the establishment that she will 'play by the rules' at least on some issues, through her neocon-style statement on Julian Assange.

Only a couple of weeks later, Politico revealed Warren's upgraded role in the anti-Sanders operation. According to a new article, "Centrists who once said the senator would lead the party to ruin are coming around to her as an alternative to Bernie Sanders." It seems almost certain …

Σοκ και δέος από την υφυπουργό εργασίας της κυβέρνησης Μητσοτάκη: "καταφέραμε να μειώσουμε πάρα πολύ το κόστος εργασίας" (!!!)

globinfo freexchange
Ήταν Απρίλιος του 2017. Η τότε σύμβουλος μεταρρυθμίσεων του Κυριάκου Μητσοτάκη και νυν υφυπουργός Εργασίας στην κυβέρνησή του, Δόμνα Μιχαηλίδου, δήλωνε στο άκρως φιλικό περιβάλλον του ΣΚΑΙ:
"Η Ελλάδα μεταξύ 2013-2014 ήταν πρωταγωνίστρια στις μεταρρυθμίσεις και στις μεταρρυθμίσεις ανταγωνιστικότητας. Και σύμφωνα με στοιχεία από τον ΟΟΣΑ και σύμφωνα με στοιχεία από την Παγκόσμια Τράπεζα, είχαμε πάρα πολύ μεγάλη άνοδο της ανταγωνιστικότητας.  [...] Καταφέραμε να μειώσουμε πάρα πολύ το κόστος εργασίας. Το εργασιακό μπήκε σε ένα πλαίσιο πιο ευέλικτο, το μισθολογικό μπήκε σε ένα πλαίσιο πολύ πιο σκληρό, οπότε καταφέραμε να μειώσουμε το κόστος εργασίας."

Προσέξτε όμως κάτι πολύ χαρακτηριστικό. Ο δημοσιογράφος του ΣΚΑΙ, πριν κάνει την ερώτησή του, παρουσιάζει ορισμένα στοιχεία που δείχνουν ότι οι χώρες με τα πιο ακριβά μεροκάματα (Ελβετία, Γερμανία) βρίσκονται στην κορυφή του πίνακα της ανταγωνιστικότητας. Επιπλέον, στην επόμενη καρτέλα, παρουσιάζει τ…

Preparing the invasion of Iran: the US empire regroups its proxies in Afghanistan

globinfo freexchange

On the occasion of the recent attack against two oil tankers in the Gulf of Oman, we estimated that the US imperialists will follow a certain scenario to achieve primary goal, which is to fully control the Strait of Hormuz. The goal could be achieved through a strategically and geographically restricted, fast-track invasion of Iran.

A certain part of the operation could include some US forces and proxies inside Afghanistan.

As we wrote, already since 2017 the US announced that it will increase the number of US troops in Afghanistan, and one reason probably has to do with Iran. A significant number of US troops on the Iranian eastern border would be very useful. It will be used to keep the Iranian forces busy and gradually weaken the Iranian operational capabilities in an extended attrition war. This will permit the US to gradually secure and establish their presence in the Strait of Hormuz.

This attrition war could be held - and probably would be more effecti…

Ο όχι και τόσο σοφός λαός έδωσε αυτοδυναμία στη χειρότερη δεξιά της μεταπολίτευσης

του system failure
Κυκλοφορεί συχνά-πυκνά το μύθευμα ότι ο λαός είναι σοφός και επιλέγει τους εκπροσώπους του με σοφία. Το συγκεκριμένο κλισέ που αναπαράγεται κοντά σε κάτι άλλα χαριτωμένα του τύπου "στη δημοκρατία δεν υπάρχουν αδιέξοδα", υπονοεί σχεδόν ότι, με κάποιον μυστηριώδη και μεταφυσικό τρόπο, μια ετερόκλητη μάζα εκατομμυρίων ψηφοφόρων καταφέρνει να συνεννοηθεί λίγο πριν από τις κάλπες για να εκλέξει ένα πολιτικά ισορροπημένο κοινοβούλιο, ότι και αν σημαίνει αυτό. 
Στις τελευταίες εκλογές, οι ψηφοφόροι έδωσαν αυτοδυναμία στην πιο νεοφιλελεύθερη δεξιά όλων των εποχών, πράγμα που εκ πρώτης όψεως φαντάζει παράλογο, ειδικά μετά από τις καταστροφικές νεοφιλελεύθερες πολιτικές που επέβαλαν οι δανειστές στα χρόνια της κρίσης. Πολιτικές που έφεραν τη χώρα και την οικονομία σε χειρότερη κατάσταση.  
Φαντάζει ακόμα πιο παράλογο και για το γεγονός ότι οι ψηφοφόροι έδωσαν αυτοδυναμία σε ένα από τα κόμματα του παλαιοκομματικού κατεστημένου, το οποίο ευθύνεται σε μεγάλο βαθ…

Πρόγραμμα ΝΔ: το απόλυτο τίποτα της νεοφιλελεύθερης καταστροφής

του system failure
Είναι πολύ εύκολο να καταλάβει κανείς το σχέδιο Μητσοτάκη για την επόμενη μέρα, με βάση αυτό που διαφημίζει ως "πρόγραμμα". Η χειρότερη δεξιά της μεταπολίτευσης, φανατικά προσηλωμένη στον καταστροφικό νεοφιλελευθερισμό, έχει ως βασικό και απ'ότι φαίνεται μοναδικό στόχο, τις επενδύσεις και την ανάπτυξη. Δηλαδή, με λίγα λόγια, ο Κυριάκος θα πατήσει ένα κουμπί και όλα τα άλλα θα τα κάνουν οι περίφημες αγορές. Θα'ρθουν επενδυτές, θα δημιουργήσουν θέσεις εργασίας, θα επιστρέψουν οι νέοι από το εξωτερικό και η νεκρή μεσαία τάξη θα αναστηθεί ως εκ θαύματος. 
Μια μεσαία τάξη που, κατά τη λογική των μιντιακώνγκεμπελίσκων και των δεξιών τρολ, καταστράφηκε επί ΣΥΡΙΖΑ. Λες και δεν υπήρχε χώρα πριν το 15. Λες και η γαλαζοπράσινη λαίλαπα δεν χρεοκόπησε τη χώρα, δεν πετσόκοψε μισθούς και συντάξεις, δεν ρήμαξε τα ασφαλιστικά ταμεία, δεν έσωσε τα τραπεζιτικά παράσιτα με δισεκατομμύρια στέλνοντας τον λογαριασμό στα συνήθη υποζύγια. 
Η αλήθεια είναι ότι…